Vol.
14, Number 2 |
April,
2005 |
Contents:
Transportation
Reauthorization Update
Alternate bid goes concrete, Asphalt pavement
costs less
ODOT to
Receive 2004 Perpetual Pavement Award
Diamond Commendations for 2004
NAPA Awards
SCIP Bond Issue Due for Renewal
Pavement Quality Customer Survey
Conferences and Seminars
Tom Letizia, Sr. Obituary
MarZane Opens New Laboratory
QuietPavement.com
Mixture Competition Won by Ohio University
Team
Ohio Hot-Mix Asphalt Current News Evolves
Transportation
Reauthorization Update
As this is written, a new 6-year
federal transportation funding bill is finally moving through
Congress. The last federal Transportation Act, TEA-21, expired
on September 30, 2003. Since then Congress has passed 6
extensions of the old act, continuing prior funding levels
and programs until May 30, 2005.
The good news for Ohio occurred
last year, when Congress approved changes to the ethanol
subsidy that will result in Gasohol being taxed at the same
rate as gasoline and returning that revenue to the transportation
trust fund. In 2006 and 2007 this will result in a substantial
increase in Ohio’s Federal funds.
The House of Representatives
has passed (March 10, 2005) a bill to re-authorize Federal
transportation programs for another six years. Generally
it constrains funding to the $284 billion favored by the
Administration and does not satisfy the equity concerns
of the donor states like Ohio.
The Bush Administration has
renewed its veto threat if the final bill exceeds $284 billion.
It also threatened a veto if the final bill includes the
"re-opener" provision contained in TEA-LU that
would shut off federal-highway funding on August 1, 2006,
unless Congress passed legislation to bring the states'
share to a minimum of 95 percent.
In the Senate, the Environment
and Public Works Committee approved on March 17th, its reauthorization
bill (SAFTEA) by a vote of 17 to 1 at the same $284 billion
funding level as the House bill. The Senate bill only guarantees
donor states a 92% return by 2009.
Neither the current House or
Senate Bills will meet Ohio’s objective of realizing
a 95% rate of return on its Federal gas tax receipts. Achieving
this more equitable rate of return was a key objective for
Ohio and a group of 23 donor states that formed the Fair
Coalition. Unfortunately, Congress seems disinclined to
cut any state’s share to fund the redistribution.
And since the administration will not accept any additional
taxes, there seems to be no will to fund the equity provision.
In order to move the highway
reauthorization bill forward, the Senate Republican leadership
must schedule time to debate SAFETEA on the Senate floor.
Until recently, many expected that time for debate would
begin on April 19 and continue unimpeded until a final vote
is taken. After that a conference committee will be needed
to reconcile the House and Senate versions. However, SAFTEA
may be stalled in the senate. The Senate has not scheduled
its bill, S. 732, for a vote. Congress has many important
priorities this year and each compete for debate time on
the Senate floor.
An adequate, 6-year transportation
funding bill is critical to meeting Ohio’s transportation
needs.
|
|
In
a presentation at the Flexible Pavements of Ohio Annual
Meeting on March 31, 2005, Michelle Holdgreve, ODOT
Deputy Director, outlined ODOT’s expectations
for Federal Funding under the pending Federal Act.
|
Reproduced
here are 2 slides from Holdgreve’s presentation.
The first shows ODOT’s projection on the results
of the pending Federal legislation. |
|
This second slide
shows trend lines of how the House, Senate and ODOT’s
projection for funding compare to that needed for
the “Jobs and Progress’ Plan.
CLICK HERE
to view a larger version of this chart. |
Unfortunately, if Ohio fails
to receive a 95% rate of return on its gas tax receipts,
it appears unlikely that Ohio’s Federal Aid will be
sufficient to fully fund the Governor’s “Jobs
and Progress” plan in the time frame originally proposed.
It may not be too late to alter
the outcome. Tell your Congressman, Senators and President
that transportation needs to be funded adequately and Ohio
deserves a more equitable rate of return on its gas tax
contributions. Contact information for Federal Officials
can be found at http://www.flexiblepavements.org/contact_officials.cfm
The Senate Majority Leader
must hear from your Republican Senators that SAFTEA is a
high priority for this state. Call the Capitol at 202-224-3121,
ask for Senators DeWine’s and Voinovich’s offices,
ask them to speak to Majority Leader Bill Frist and press
for immediate consideration of "S. 732" - the
SAFETEA bill. Join other industry representatives in attending
the Transportation Coalition Fly-in to Washington, D.C.
on April 26 and 27, 2005 and tell them again in person.
Alternate
bid goes concrete, Asphalt pavement costs less.
You may have heard that ODOT’s
latest alternate pavement type bid project went to a contractor
that bid the concrete pavement alternative. What you may
not know, unless you’ve had the opportunity to review
the bid tabs for the project, is that the bids for the asphalt
pavement alternative were substantially lower than the winning
bid, which included a concrete pavement.
The project was #108 (2005),
Ashtabula, IR 90, 3.70. The pavement alternates were 68,199
cy of 7-year warranty asphalt pavement vs. 171,966 sy of
13 in. plain concrete, 7-year warranty pavement. The project
included a maintenance bid penalty against asphalt of $339,
920. The project estimate was $14,710,000.
Oddly, there was only one concrete
bid on this project. Usually, ODOT receives multiple bids
for concrete pavement projects. There were 2 bids for the
asphalt pavement alternative. Prices bid for the pavement
items are tabulated as follows:
The concrete pavement bidder
won the project with lower bid prices in a number of other
categories other than pavement. Even with the maintenance
penalty ($339,920) applied, the average of the 2 asphalt
pavement bids would have been 10% less expensive than the
concrete pavement bid.
So, although, “the race
does not always to the swiftest go”; this project,
like the many other alternate bid projects that have gone
before it, demonstrates that asphalt pavement is still the
more economical alternative.
ODOT to Receive
2004 Perpetual Pavement Award
ODOT, District 2 has been notified
that it is to be a recipient of the Asphalt Pavement Alliance’s
2004 Perpetual Pavement Award. The Award will be presented
by the President of the American Association of State Highway
and Transportation Officials, Jack Lattiere, Jr., at a special
ceremony May 18th, 2005 at the National Center for Asphalt
Technology, Auburn University, Alabama.
The award is being presented
for a 5-mile section of SR 25 in Wood County near Toledo.
The asphalt pavement project was constructed 67 years ago
and has received only maintenance overlays at an average
interval of 15 years since.
Diamond Commendations
for 2004
We want to congratulate those
producer members who received NAPA’s Diamond Achievement
Commendation in 2004 for excellence in plant operations.
The full List of Ohio Recipients is as follows:
Barrett Paving Materials,
Inc.
Plants: Carthage, Fairborn,
Moraine, Newtown, Pleasant Run and #111, Sidney.
Kokosing Materials,
Inc.
Plants; Fredericktown and Mansfield.
Shelly and Sands, Inc.
Plants: Mar-Zane #2, #21 and #29.
The Shelly Co.
Downtown Plant #76.
Valley Asphalt Corp.
Plants #6, #9, #14, #17, #19, #23 and #25.
NAPA Awards
At the NAPA convention Ohio
contractors were recognized for their National Asphalt Pavement
Association, Quality in Construction Awards as follows:
Projects less than 50,000
tons:
John
R. Jurgensen Co. – Greene & Clermont
counties U.S. Route 35/U.S. Route 32, ODOT Project 386(2004);
Clermont County S.R. 28, ODOT Project 423(2003)
The
Shelly Company, Twinsburg Division – Rehabilitation
of Runway 7-25, Lorain County Regional Airport
Projects greater than 50,000
tons:
John
R. Jurgensen Co. – Hamilton County I-275,
ODOT Project 32(2002)
Kokosing
Construction Co. – Fairfield U.S. Route 33,
Phase III, ODOT Project 446(2002)
ECOLOGICAL AWARD FOR HMA FACILITIES
Valley
Asphalt Corp., Troy – finalist for Existing
Facility Category
SCIP Bond
Issue Due for Renewal
The state constitutional amendment
and bond issue that has provided almost $2.3 billion in
funding for infrastructure repairs over the last 20 years
is again due for renewal. The Ohio Public Works Commission
administers the State Capital Improvement Program (SCIP)
grant program for local governments. The Ohio legislature
has approved placing this issue before the voters once again
during the November, 2005 general election. This issue is
critical to local governments in funding their public works
improvements. For more information, read the article in
the next issue of Ohio Asphalt magazine by Hamilton County
Engineer, William Brayshaw. A campaign will be needed to
inform the voters of the importance of renewing this program.
Be prepared to support the campaign to assure renewal of
this program.
Pavement Quality
Customer Survey in Progress
Flexible Pavements of Ohio
has partnered with several public works organizations to
conduct a survey of the quality of asphalt pavements in
Ohio. FPO’s partners in this project are the County
Engineer’s Association of Ohio (CEAO), the American
Public Works Association, Ohio Chapter (APWA), the American
Council of Engineering Consultants, Ohio Chapter (ACEC)
and the Municipal Engineer’s Association on Northeast
Ohio (MEANEO). A parallel survey has been sent to industry
representatives to obtain the industry perspective, in addition
to that of our customers. Surveys were sent out at the end
of February and are currently being received and the results
tabulated.
FPO will analyze the results
of the survey and report to our partners, Board of Directors
and members. It is expected that the results of the survey
will help to guide the association’s future efforts
toward improving the quality of asphalt pavement construction
in Ohio.
If you have not yet filled
out and returned your survey questionnaire, it’s not
too late. FPO will be accepting and analyzing the survey
results through May 2005.
Conferences
and Seminars Completed for the Winter
Winter is conference and seminar
season in the asphalt industry and this winter was an especially
busy one for FPO.
It all began with the Ohio
Asphalt Paving Conference at the OSU Fawcett Center
in Columbus on February 3rd. 359 registered to learn the
latest information on asphalt pavement technology. All presentations
were outstanding. Gerald Huber’s report on the state
of asphalt pavement construction in China and William Pine’s
case study of the re-paving of the Indianapolis Motor Speedway
were real crowd pleasers. Donna Harmelink of the Colorado
FHWA reported on the investigation of paver induced segregation
in Colorado. Reports of the investigation can be found at:
Top Down Cracking - http://www.dot.state.co.us/Publications/PDFFiles/topdowncracking.pdf
Next up was our annual training
for mix designers at the ODOT lab from February 28 through
March 4th. This training and exam leads to ODOT Level 3
approval for laboratory technicians.

We then took our show on the
road to the Cleveland area on February 23, 2005 to conduct
a seminar on rehabilitation of concrete pavements. This
was a free seminar and trade show for Municipal Engineers
and Public Works Directors. Member companies who sponsored,
exhibited and presented at the seminar were: Meredith
Brothers, Highway Rubber Products,
Resource International and PS Construction
Fabrics.
The big show of the season,
our 43rd, Annual Meeting and Equipment Exhibition
occurred March 30 and 31, 2005. Talk about educational opportunities!
The meeting included 3 concurrent seminars on Porous Pavement
Design, Compaction and Plant Operations; and 10 other presentations,
including the keynote address by Auditor of State, Betty
Montgomery. ODOT Deputy Directors, Howard Wood and Michelle
Holdgreve, reported on ODOT’s future construction
program plans and funding forecasts. (Howard Wood’s
presentation on ODOT’s 2006-2007 pavement construction
program can be viewed in abbreviated form at http://www.flexiblepavements.org/images/wood.pdf).
Other activities of the Annual
meeting included a roundtable discussion of asphalt issues
of concern to local governments, a trade show with a lot
full of equipment, presentation of our Annual Awards and
scholarships and our regular business and committee meetings.
In the meantime, Gerken Paving
sponsored meetings in northwest Ohio with public agency
personnel from Paulding, Williams and Defiance Counties
on February 24, and March 25, 2005 for us to make presentations
on asphalt specifications.
We try to present an educational
opportunity at least every quarter, so watch www.flexiblepavements.org
for announcements of future seminars and conferences.
Tom Letizia,
Sr. Passes
Gaetano
(Tom) Letizia, Sr., founder of Unique Paving Materials Corporation
and inventor of UPM® Permanent Pavement Repair Material
passed away on Wednesday, March 30th, 2005 at the age of
89.
Tom Letizia was born on August
3, 1915 and was raised in Cleveland’s oldest Italian
neighborhood known as “Orange Avenue”. He began
his career selling newspapers in downtown Cleveland on East
9th Street during the Great Depression. He attended East
Tech High School and was a member of the CCC (Civilian Conservation
Corps.). After twenty years of experience as a laborer,
foreman and partner in the paving business, Tom formed his
own company in the mid 1950s, which now employs over 40
people based in Cleveland, Ohio along with producers and
distributors around the globe. His company motto was “Where
Quality & Service Count” and he lived by it.
Tom was the recipient of the
“Lifetime Achievement Award” from the American
Public Works Association (APWA) for his service and dedication
to the industry.
Tom was recipient of the “William
W. “Bill” Baker Award” From Flexible Pavements
of Ohio in 2004 for his contribution to the asphalt industry,
being known to many as the “grandfather” of
the high performance asphalt cold mix industry.
MarZane Opens
New Laboratory
MarZane
Materials Division of Shelly and Sands, Inc. opened its
new materials laboratory facility with an open house on
April 8, 2005. The state of the art facility is located
at SR 555 near SR 719 near Zanesville Ohio.

How can quiet
pavement technology reduce road noise?
Find out at QuietPavement.com:
an interactive learning experience about the impact of road
noise in our lives as well as methods for reducing road
noise using hot mix asphalt.
==============================
Activities @ QuietPavement.com
==============================
1) SoundTown USA
Build your own neighborhood and discover how you can reduce
road noise inside your home.
2) How Loud Is Loud?
Learn what a blender, a barking dog, and a vacuum cleaner
can teach us about road noise.
3) Come Hear!
Every day we are exposed to thousands of sounds. How does
the human ear translate these sounds to become noises?
4) History of Road Noise
Why did Julius Caesar stop traffic noise at its source back
in 44 BC in the History of Road Noise.
5) Test Drive
What's the difference between concrete highways and asphalt
highways? See for yourself in this test drive video.
--------------------------------------
© 2005 Asphalt Pavement Alliance
Mixture Competition
Won by Ohio University Team
Flexible Pavements of Ohio
sponsors an asphalt mixture performance competition for
Ohio’s Civil Engineering colleges. In this competition,
student teams have to design a HMA mixture to resist rutting.
Teams are supplied the same aggregates (courtesy of Martin
Marietta Aggregates) and may use any combination of binder
and additives. Teams have to perform the laboratory mix
design tests, using a university or FPO member lab, write
a report and give an oral presentation. Mixes are tested
for rut depth at the ODOT laboratory, and reports and presentations
are judged by a panel of industry experts. The competition
requires a great deal of extra effort on the part of students
and faculty advisors; and, of course, wouldn’t be
possible without the cooperation of many FPO producer members
and their laboratory personnel.
The winning team for this year
is Ohio University, team members: Yun Liao, Jonathan Kovach
and Brett Mann. Their faculty advisor is Dr. Sang-Soo Kim.
Second place went to Ohio Northern
University: Jerod Hiller, Nick Lake and Danielle Brinkman.
Faculty advisor is Dr. Kanok Boriboonsomsin.
Third place went to Youngstown
State University: Hadi Chammas, Jeanna Cunningham, Deyhna
Harville and Jonathan Locketti. Faculty advisor is Dr. Shakir
Husain.
The winning Ohio University
team goes on to a national competition against teams from
other universities from around the nation. The national
competition is judged by NCAT. Ohio looks forward to bringing
the national title back to Ohio, after losing it last year
to Michigan Tech.
Ohio Hot-Mix
Asphalt Current News Evolves.
We’ve changed again.
Since we began our e-mail newsletter with the July, 2003
issue, Ohio HMA Current News has been distributed as an
HTML and as a PDF document. With this issue we’re
transitioning to an HTML format that will accommodate the
inclusion of pictures and graphics. We hope you’ll
find this version an improvement.
Are you on
our mailing list?
In addition to this e-news
letter, FPO publishes a quarterly magazine, Ohio
Asphalt. The Spring 2005 issue of Ohio
Asphalt will be mailed in May, 2005. To add your
address to the mail lists for the e-news letter and/or the
magazine, send a request with your address information to
flexpave@ameritech.net.
This E-mail newsletter is distributed
by opt-in only, by Flexible Pavements of Ohio. To be included
on the distribution you must have requested to be included.
Conversely, if you wish to be removed from this distribution,
just let us know at flexpave@ameritech.net.